[Illusion]

Originally Posted by ml1201

I've been wondering something, did Lady Scrimshaw get the only meal that was specifically made to her tastes (being a lighter meal) or were the rest of the meals also made to try and fit what they seem to like?

You should ask Alabaster that...

[ml1201]

But I used all three of my questions. ^^;

[MonBon]

I don't think that characters dying really clears anyone. And Then There Were None taught me that. All it does is make it so we can interrogate less people :(

[CupcakeDolly]

I've been wondering about that as well, so I'll go ahead and ask.
Pchoooo!

[ml1201]

Thank you cupcake! XD *snuggles*

[Salone]

Hey ml, no worries! The questions are reset whenever a new chapter is posted, so you can ask away again! I'll be home in a sec and then I can update answers for questions from the interrogation thread.

[CupcakeDolly]

Damn, I have at least three different theories floating in my head now.
Just gotta see who dies.
DIE, DAMN YOU!
(Everyone in the story is kind of an awful person, so I don't feel too bad about shouting that)

[Illusion]

Originally Posted by CupcakeDolly

Damn, I have at least three different theories floating in my head now.
Just gotta see who dies.
DIE, DAMN YOU!
(Everyone in the story is kind of an awful person, so I don't feel too bad about shouting that)

Alabaster is the only genuinely decent person, everyone else are kind of asses.
But still. IT'S ALWAYS THE BUTLER. ALWAYS. And for all eternity!

[ml1201]

I have my suspicion as being Tavish, he actually gains the most out of the two deaths. Which is the reason I asked those questions to verify my suspicions. :3

[CupcakeDolly]

Originally Posted by Illusion

Alabaster is the only genuinely decent person, everyone else are kind of asses.
But still. IT'S ALWAYS THE BUTLER. ALWAYS. And for all eternity!

That's part of why I suspect him though! He is just... too NICE.

I have my suspicions about Tavish too. But like I said... it won't be any clearer until someone else dies.

[ml1201]

So this still makes it possible for an outsider to have done the murder, while actually trying to kill Lady Scrimshaw.

[Gallagher]

An outsider? Oh dear...

The Murderer: Lawtan

How they did it: Carefully

Why: he 2 spoopy

[MonBon]

Originally Posted by Gallagher

An outsider? Oh dear...

The Murderer: Lawtan

How they did it: Carefully

Why: he 2 spoopy

I agree

[Lawtan]

You caught me. *hangs head*
XD
Nah, I am more likely to think that the two murders are done for different reasons by different people.

I am sort of between three or four folk. Alabaster is the only one I am discounting because of cliche and way too easy to pin it on him.

[CupcakeDolly]

Pretty sure there's only one killer? If there's more than one, that would be a bitch to solve, as we'd have to get the right combination of killers and motives in order to win.
And Salone wouldn't be that lame.
Right?
...Right?

[MonBon]

This might have been answered already, but do the characters have to respond honestly to our interrogation questions?