[Lawtan]

I tend to go for color and consistency over both. Mixing very simple animation with hyper-realistic stuff (Chowder, Ren & Stimpy, Flapjack) are visually revolting to me.

On the other hand, early CGI and 3D games (terrible graphics) have an appeal because they match their environment. Though it may be I liked the mechanics and story better.

Exception being ones like Courage the Cowardly Dog - though the surreal CGI in a cartoon scared many, it was a "simple CGI in a simple cartoon" thing.

After a point, detail does lose it for me - largely due to my terrible eyesight (bad visual depth personally). On the other hand, I mentally pay attention to the quality of the detail I see. I hope that makes sense.