[Quiet Man Cometh]

I find I'm more interested in the stuff that goes cult, or ends up doing better after the whole theater/critic deal.

American Psycho was one, starting Christian Bale. A number of people I know have never heard of that movie, It didn't do well in theaters, can't recall what critics thought of it, but it got the most attention when it arrived on video (when I first watched it) and it developed a modest cult following.

It was definately unusual, though did have the side effect of a permanent image of Christian Bale's character enthusiastically beheading his roommate throughout my watching of Batman Begins.