[Quiet Man Cometh]

New post because I'd rather not tackle too many topics or ideas in one go. Makes things look plugged, and the last post was fairly big.

Originally Posted by Suzerain of Sheol

@Quiet, that's very sound and sensible (as your points usually are), the only thing I'd raise in counter to it is that in the beginning of the Silm., before Morgoth steals the Silmmarils and Ungoliant kills the Trees of Light, the elves are all happy and enjoying making beautiful things like you mentioned above, and they still don't act like that.

Not sure entirely what your talking about here, Suzerain. What is it in particular that the elves (pre morgoth or post, not sure) aren't really doing?