Trisphee - View Single Post

Suzerain of Sheol · Posted 05-30-2011, 11:20 PM

Am I forgetting a scene (which is possible, I can see Jackson having more than one elf insult Gimli :p) or do you mean Haldir in Lothlorien who later comes to Helm's Deep.

As he wasn't really a character in the books, he got by okay, but he was a walking plothole in the movie. :p

Seriously, he brings word from who? There's no feasible way Haldir could have met the company in Lothlorien, rode to Rivendell to gather those 200 elves and then made it to Helm's Deep in time. Rivendell's on the other side of the Misty Mountains, for Eru's sake.

Meh, maybe Jackson's elves can telelport. :p

		#12	Suzerain of Sheol Desolation Denizen
Am I forgetting a scene (which is possible, I can see Jackson having more than one elf insult Gimli :p) or do you mean Haldir in Lothlorien who later comes to Helm's Deep. As he wasn't really a character in the books, he got by okay, but he was a walking plothole in the movie. :p Seriously, he brings word from who? There's no feasible way Haldir could have met the company in Lothlorien, rode to Rivendell to gather those 200 elves and then made it to Helm's Deep in time. Rivendell's on the other side of the Misty Mountains, for Eru's sake. Meh, maybe Jackson's elves can telelport. :p Cold silence has a tendency to atrophy any sense of compassion between supposed lovers. Between supposed brothers.
	Posted 05-30-2011, 11:20 PM