[Illusion]

Originally Posted by Coda

Honestly it doesn't actually make much of a difference from a management perspective.

As for looking smaller, it's a trade-off. You can have a forum that looks smaller but more active, or a forum that looks bigger but less active. Toho's comment about forums with two-year-old threads on the front page is a sign that we were too far on the "less active" side of things, and activity is the main thing that drives a website -- if people see other people being active, they themselves are more likely to be active. Meanwhile, if a person doesn't see a lot of other activity, they're more likely to just forget to come back.

Originally Posted by Sei

We are watching and we can make adjustments if the admin team feels that a further change would better suit the community.

As I said before - let's say, music starts to dominate the media forum and it's hard to find threads on other topics for a significant amount of time (to rule out spikes in activity) - in that case, we would split the music topics off into a music subforum to allow other topics to breathe. If the subforum were to grow large enough that it would need it's own sub-subforums, then we as admins would discuss promoting the forum to a main forum. It's kind of a weird forum evolution of sorts.

I think this will definitely help us to appear busier, which will encourage people to post more, which in turn will help the forums grow. If a certain topic is popular enough, it may very well become a main forum again.

If this is how you guys are handling it, then that would be absolutely perfect.