[Quiet Man Cometh]

I forgot this event was even a thing! So here's my preliminary thoughts from just reading the events so far. Will see how things change when I get to character profiles (haven't read those yet).

The Murderer: The Butler! (AKA Alabaster)

How they did it: accident. He's a bit of a flake it seems. Misplaces the wine, goes to get another one, finds it again. He may well have accidentally dumped his meds into the ham in place of some other spice bottle, perhaps ground up, which would be why he couldn't find them later.

Why: again, accident.


Could be that Captain Bosney is a little quick to judge, hence Isabelle asking about the previous fellow that was shot, and her comments at dinner.

Alternatively, Alabaster is actually a very cunning and meticulous man and cultivated the impression of being flakey so that we would expect an accident!.