[Lawtan]

I admit I am partly in Ashy's court - I find Rise of the Guardians to be better. It wasn't the musical...it was because it was so much of a musical (and the instruments used in one of the songs just doesn't fit the atmosphere...and though they threw several good twists with the love in the plot (IMO) they needed more build up than the "wanna build a snowman" song to develop everyone more...

In short, I wish that the wasted hour in Hobbit was used to add 30 minutes to Frozen's beginnings to pace it better.

Rise of the Guardians 79/100
Frozen 68/100
Hobbit 2 46/100

...then again, my favorite childhood movies would score a 60/100, so...