[Gallagher]

Except it's not, because one's behavior in unimportant situations, like a wallet, and their behavior in important ones, like war changing ones, are completely and utterly different. If we are only talking about a wallet, then yes, give it back, no matter who its owner is. If we're talking about something that changes more than just that... It still depends. Forgive me for going HP for a moment here, but if something good could come of it like what happened with a certain headmaster's death, then...